Organic ChemistryAll courses

Chapter 1: Structure and Bonding, lesson 2

Molecular shape

A Lewis structure is flat. Molecules are not. This lesson is a quick return to VSEPR, with one change of habit, which is to find the shape at every atom in the molecule and not only at one central atom.

  • About 15 minutes
  • 5 sections
  • 9 practice questions
  • Narrated

After this lesson you can

  • Count the electron groups around any atom in a Lewis structure.
  • Predict the arrangement and the bond angles for two, three and four groups.
  • Explain why lone pairs make bond angles smaller.
  • Describe the shape at each atom of a larger molecule.
  • Read and draw wedge and dash bonds.

Warm-up check

Five quick questions from AP Chemistry. If you get them all, skim the first three sections and slow down at "Shape at every atom".

  1. 1.What is the shape of a methane molecule, CH4?

    Question 1: choose one
    See the answer

    Carbon has four bonds and no lone pairs. Four groups point to the corners of a tetrahedron.

  2. 2.What is the shape of a carbon dioxide molecule, CO2?

    Question 2: choose one
    See the answer

    Carbon has two double bonds and no lone pairs. Each double bond is one group, and two groups point in opposite directions.

  3. 3.How many lone pairs are on the nitrogen atom in ammonia, NH3?

    See the answer

    Nitrogen has 5 valence electrons. Three go into the three N–H bonds, and the other two make one lone pair.

  4. 4.What is the shape of a water molecule?

    Question 4: choose one
    See the answer

    Oxygen has two bonds and two lone pairs. The four groups are arranged like a tetrahedron, and the three atoms make a bent shape.

  5. 5.Which molecule is flat, with all of its atoms in one plane?

    Question 5: choose one
    See the answer

    Boron in BF3 has three bonds and no lone pairs, so it is trigonal planar. The others have four groups around the central atom.

Electron groups push each other apart

Electrons repel each other. The electrons around an atom sit in groups, and the groups get as far from each other as they can. That one idea, called VSEPR, predicts the shape around almost every atom you will meet in this course.

An electron group is anything that holds electrons in one region next to the atom. Each of these counts as one group:

  • a single bond
  • a double bond
  • a triple bond
  • a lone pair

A double bond is four electrons, but they all sit between the same two atoms, so they act as one group. The same is true of a triple bond.

Key idea

To count groups, count the atoms bonded to your atom, then add its lone pairs. Ignore whether the bonds are single, double or triple.

Three arrangements cover organic chemistry

In AP Chemistry you learned arrangements for up to six groups. Carbon, nitrogen and oxygen never have more than four, so three arrangements do nearly all the work.

Four groups point to the corners of a tetrahedron. The angle between any two is 109.5°.[OpenStax Chemistry 7.6] Methane, CH4, is the model case. Turn it and notice that no view makes it look flat.

Loading 3D model of methane…

Methane. Four groups, tetrahedral, 109.5° between any two bonds.
Describe this model

Methane is a carbon atom at the center of a tetrahedron, with a hydrogen atom at each of the four corners. Every hydrogen is the same distance from every other hydrogen. One angle between two bonds is labeled 109.5 degrees.

Three groups lie flat and point to the corners of a triangle, 120° apart.[OpenStax Chemistry 7.6] This is called trigonal planar. The carbon in formaldehyde, CH2O, has three groups: two single bonds and one double bond.

Loading 3D model of formaldehyde…

Formaldehyde. Three groups around carbon, trigonal planar, close to 120°.
Describe this model

Formaldehyde is flat. Carbon is in the middle, with oxygen and two hydrogens around it at the corners of a triangle. The angle between the two bonds to hydrogen is labeled about 120 degrees.

Two groups point in opposite directions, 180° apart, which makes a straight line.[OpenStax Chemistry 7.6] The carbon in hydrogen cyanide, HCN, has two groups: one single bond and one triple bond.

Loading 3D model of hydrogen cyanide…

Hydrogen cyanide. Two groups around carbon, linear, 180°.
Describe this model

Hydrogen cyanide is a straight rod of three atoms: hydrogen, then carbon, then nitrogen. The angle at carbon is labeled 180 degrees.

Key idea

Four groups: tetrahedral, 109.5°. Three groups: trigonal planar, 120°. Two groups: linear, 180°.[OpenStax Chemistry 7.6]

Lone pairs take up room

A lone pair is a group, so it takes one of the positions. But you cannot see a lone pair in a model, so the shape you name is the shape the atoms make.

The nitrogen in ammonia, NH3, has four groups: three bonds and one lone pair. The groups are arranged like a tetrahedron, but only three corners hold atoms. The atoms make a short pyramid with nitrogen at the top. That shape is called trigonal pyramidal.

Loading 3D model of ammonia…

Ammonia. Switch the lone pair off to see the shape the atoms make by themselves.
Describe this model

Ammonia is a short pyramid. Nitrogen is at the top and three hydrogens make the base. A lobe on top of nitrogen, pointing away from the hydrogens, shows the lone pair. The angle between two bonds is labeled about 107 degrees.

The angle between the bonds in ammonia is about 107°, a little less than 109.5°.[OpenStax Chemistry 7.6] A bonding pair is stretched between two nuclei. A lone pair is held by only one nucleus, so it spreads out wider near its atom. It pushes the three bonds slightly closer together.

The oxygen in water has four groups too: two bonds and two lone pairs. Two lone pairs push harder than one, so the angle closes further, to 104.5°.[OpenStax Chemistry 7.6] The three atoms make a shape called bent.

Loading 3D model of water…

Water. Two bonds and two lone pairs around oxygen.
Describe this model

Water is bent, like a wide letter V with oxygen at the point and a hydrogen at each end. Two lobes on oxygen, pointing away from the hydrogens, show the two lone pairs. The angle between the two bonds is labeled 104.5 degrees.

Key idea

Count lone pairs when you choose the arrangement. Leave them out when you name the shape. Each lone pair squeezes the bond angles a little below the ideal value.

Shape at every atom

Here is the change of habit. In AP Chemistry most molecules had one central atom, and you named one shape for the whole molecule. Organic molecules are chains and rings, and there is no single center. So you describe the shape at each atom, one atom at a time.

Acetic acid, CH3CO2H, is the acid in vinegar. Look at three of its atoms in turn.

CHHHCOOH
Acetic acid, CH3CO2H.
Describe this figure

Lewis structure of acetic acid. Carbon has three hydrogens and a single bond to carbon. Carbon has a single bond to carbon, a double bond to oxygen, and a single bond to oxygen. Oxygen has a double bond to carbon and two lone pairs. Oxygen has one hydrogen, a single bond to carbon, and two lone pairs.

The first carbon is bonded to three hydrogens and a carbon. That is four groups, so it is tetrahedral. The second carbon is bonded to a carbon and two oxygens. That is three groups, so it is trigonal planar. The oxygen that carries the hydrogen has two bonds and two lone pairs. That is four groups, so it is bent, like the oxygen in water.

Loading 3D model of acetic acid…

Acetic acid. Find the tetrahedral carbon, the flat carbon and the bent oxygen.
Describe this model

Acetic acid has two carbons in a row. The first carbon carries three hydrogens that fan out like the legs of a tripod. The second carbon is flat: its three neighbors, the first carbon and two oxygens, lie around it in one plane. One oxygen is joined by a shorter double bond. The other oxygen carries a hydrogen, and the bonds at that oxygen make a bent shape.

Now you try. Count the electron groups around each labeled atom.

Try it: methylamine, CH3NH2

CaHHHNbHH
Describe this figure

Lewis structure of methylamine, CH3NH2. Carbon a has three hydrogens and a single bond to nitrogen. Nitrogen b has two hydrogens, a single bond to carbon, and one lone pair.

Electron groups around carbon a
Electron groups around nitrogen b
Show the count

Count the atoms attached plus the lone pairs:

  • Carbon a: 4 atoms attached + 0 lone pairs = 4 groups
  • Nitrogen b: 3 atoms attached + 1 lone pair = 4 groups

Try it: acetaldehyde, CH3CHO

CaHHHCbOH
Describe this figure

Lewis structure of acetaldehyde, CH3CHO. Carbon a has three hydrogens and a single bond to carbon. Carbon b has one hydrogen, a single bond to carbon, and a double bond to oxygen. Oxygen has a double bond to carbon and two lone pairs.

Electron groups around carbon a
Electron groups around carbon b
Show the count

Count the atoms attached plus the lone pairs:

  • Carbon a: 4 atoms attached + 0 lone pairs = 4 groups
  • Carbon b: 3 atoms attached + 0 lone pairs = 3 groups

Showing three dimensions on paper

A tetrahedral atom cannot be drawn flat without losing something. Organic chemists fix this with two special bonds.

  • A plain line is a bond that lies in the plane of the paper.
  • A solid wedge is a bond that comes out of the paper toward you. The wide end is the near end.
  • A dashed wedge is a bond that goes back behind the paper, away from you.
CHHHH

Flat drawing

Shows the connections. The right angles are not real.

CHHHH

Methane in 3D

Two bonds in the paper, one toward you, one away.

NHHH

Ammonia in 3D

The lone pair sits where the fourth bond would be.

The usual way to draw a tetrahedral atom is the one shown for methane: two plain bonds making a V, then one wedge and one dash side by side in the space that is left. You will need this notation in the chapter on stereochemistry, where the direction of a bond in space changes what the molecule is.

Key concepts

Count the groups

Atoms bonded to it, plus lone pairs on it. A double or triple bond is one group.

Three arrangements

Four groups are tetrahedral. Three groups are trigonal planar. Two groups are linear.

Lone pairs

They take a position but are not part of the shape’s name. Ammonia is trigonal pyramidal and water is bent. Lone pairs make the bond angles slightly smaller.

Every atom has a shape

In a chain or a ring, work out the shape one atom at a time.

Wedge and dash

A solid wedge comes toward you. A dashed wedge goes away. A plain line stays in the paper.

Practice

0 of 9 solved

Check each answer as you go. If you get stuck, open the hint first, then the text solution.

  1. Q1groupsOpen

    The carbon atom in carbon dioxide, CO2, has two double bonds and no lone pairs. How many electron groups does it have?

    Hint

    A double bond is four electrons, but they all sit between the same two atoms.

    Text solution
    1. Each double bond counts as one group.
    2. Two double bonds make 2 groups, so the molecule is linear.
  2. Q2groups, anglesOpen

    Acetaldehyde, CH3CHO, is shown. Answer for each labeled carbon.

    CaHHHCbOH
    Describe this figure

    Lewis structure of acetaldehyde. Carbon a has three hydrogens and a single bond to carbon. Carbon b has one hydrogen, a single bond to carbon, and a double bond to oxygen. Oxygen has a double bond to carbon and two lone pairs.

    (a) Shape at carbon a

    Question 2 part a: choose one

    (b) Shape at carbon b

    Question 2 part b: choose one
    Hint

    Count the atoms bonded to each carbon. Neither carbon has a lone pair.

    Text solution
    1. Carbon a is bonded to three hydrogens and a carbon: four groups, tetrahedral.
    2. Carbon b is bonded to a carbon, an oxygen and a hydrogen: three groups, trigonal planar. The double bond to oxygen is one group.
  3. Q3anglesOpen

    Propyne, CH3C≡CH, is shown. What is the ideal bond angle at each labeled carbon?

    CaHHHCbCH
    Describe this figure

    Lewis structure of propyne. Carbon a has three hydrogens and a single bond to carbon. Carbon b has a single bond to carbon and a triple bond to carbon. Carbon has one hydrogen and a triple bond to carbon.

    (a) Angle at carbon a

    Question 3 part a: choose one

    (b) Angle at carbon b

    Question 3 part b: choose one
    Hint

    Carbon a has four atoms bonded to it. Carbon b has two.

    Text solution
    1. Carbon a has four groups, so its bonds are 109.5° apart.
    2. Carbon b has two groups, a single bond and a triple bond, so its bonds are 180° apart. The three carbons lie in a straight line.
  4. Q4lone pairsOpen

    Methanol, CH3OH, is shown. What is the shape at oxygen a?

    CHHHOaH
    Describe this figure

    Lewis structure of methanol. Carbon has three hydrogens and a single bond to oxygen. Oxygen a has one hydrogen, a single bond to carbon, and two lone pairs.

    Question 4: choose one
    Hint

    Count the lone pairs to choose the arrangement. Leave them out when you name the shape.

    Text solution
    1. Oxygen has two bonds and two lone pairs, which makes four groups.
    2. Four groups are arranged like a tetrahedron, but only two positions hold atoms.
    3. The carbon, the oxygen and the hydrogen make a bent shape, as in water.
  5. Q5lone pairs, anglesOpen

    Methane, ammonia and water each have four electron groups around the central atom. Which has the smallest angle between its bonds?

    Question 5: choose one
    Hint

    A lone pair spreads out more than a bonding pair. How many lone pairs does each molecule have?

    Text solution
    1. Methane has no lone pairs, ammonia has one and water has two.
    2. Each lone pair pushes the bonds closer together.
    3. Water has the most lone pairs, so it has the smallest angle, 104.5°.
  6. Q6groupsOpen

    The methyl cation, CH3+, has a carbon with three bonds to hydrogen and no lone pairs. What is its shape?

    Question 6: choose one
    Hint

    Count the groups. An empty position is not a group, because there are no electrons in it.

    Text solution
    1. The carbon has three bonds and nothing else, so it has three groups.
    2. Three groups are trigonal planar. A carbocation is flat, with 120° between its bonds.
  7. Q7lone pairsOpen

    The methyl anion, CH3−, has a carbon with three bonds to hydrogen and one lone pair. Which molecule has the same shape?

    Question 7: choose one
    Hint

    Find the molecule whose central atom also has three bonds and one lone pair.

    Text solution
    1. Three bonds and one lone pair make four groups.
    2. The atoms make a pyramid, the same trigonal pyramidal shape as ammonia.
  8. Q8wedge dashOpen

    In a drawing, a bond is shown as a solid wedge. Where does that bond point?

    Question 8: choose one
    Hint

    The wide end of the wedge is the end that is nearer to you.

    Text solution
    1. A solid wedge comes out of the paper toward you.
    2. A dashed wedge goes behind the paper, and a plain line stays in the paper.
  9. Q9groups, anglesOpen

    In acetic acid, CH3CO2H, the second carbon is bonded to a carbon, to an oxygen by a double bond, and to an OH group. About what is the angle between the two carbon–oxygen bonds?

    Question 9: choose one
    Hint

    Count the atoms bonded to that carbon.

    Text solution
    1. The carbon has three atoms bonded to it and no lone pairs, so it has three groups.
    2. Three groups are trigonal planar, with angles close to 120°.

Sources

  • OpenStax Chemistry 7.6. Flowers, P.; Theopold, K.; Langley, R.; Robinson, W. R. Chemistry 2e, section 7.6, Molecular Structure and Polarity. OpenStax, 2019. https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/7-6-molecular-structure-and-polarity

How did it go?

Sections read: 0%. Practice: 0 answered.

How was this lesson?