Organic ChemistryAll courses

Chapter 1: Structure and Bonding, lesson 3

Bond polarity and dipole moments

Electrons in a bond are shared, but rarely shared equally. Knowing which end of a bond is electron-poor and which is electron-rich is the first step toward predicting where a molecule will react.

  • About 15 minutes
  • 6 sections
  • 9 practice questions
  • Narrated

After this lesson you can

  • Use electronegativity to decide which end of a bond is partly negative.
  • Mark a polar bond with partial charges or a dipole arrow.
  • Decide whether the bond dipoles in a molecule cancel or add up.
  • Explain why shape matters as much as the bonds do.
  • Find the electron-poor and electron-rich atoms in an organic molecule.

Warm-up check

Five quick questions from AP Chemistry. If these feel easy, read quickly until "Same bonds, different shape".

  1. 1.Which of these elements has the highest electronegativity?

    Question 1: choose one
    See the answer

    Electronegativity rises from left to right across a row. Fluorine is the farthest right of the four, and it is the most electronegative element of all.

  2. 2.In a molecule of hydrogen chloride, HCl, which atom is partly negative?

    Question 2: choose one
    See the answer

    Chlorine is more electronegative than hydrogen, so the shared electrons spend more time near chlorine.

  3. 3.Which of these bonds is nonpolar?

    Question 3: choose one
    See the answer

    Two atoms of the same element pull equally, so the electrons in Cl–Cl are shared evenly.

  4. 4.Is a carbon dioxide molecule, CO2, polar?

    Question 4: choose one
    See the answer

    Each C=O bond is polar, but the molecule is linear. The two bond dipoles point in opposite directions and cancel.

  5. 5.Is a water molecule polar?

    Question 5: choose one
    See the answer

    Water is bent, so its two O–H bond dipoles do not cancel. The oxygen end is partly negative.

Sharing is rarely equal

Formal charge pretends that the two atoms in a bond share its electrons evenly. Real atoms do not. Electronegativity measures how strongly an atom pulls the shared electrons toward itself. On the usual scale the numbers run from about 1 to 4.[OpenStax Organic 2.1]

These are the values you will use most in this course.

  • Fluorine: 4.0
  • Oxygen: 3.5
  • Nitrogen and chlorine: 3.0
  • Bromine: 2.8
  • Carbon: 2.5
  • Hydrogen: 2.1
  • Magnesium: 1.2
  • Lithium: 1.0

You do not need to memorize the numbers. Remember the order, and remember where carbon sits. Carbon is near the middle. Oxygen, nitrogen and the halogens pull harder than carbon does. Metals pull much less. Hydrogen is so close to carbon that the two share almost evenly.

Key idea

Electronegativity rises as you go right across a row of the periodic table and up a column. Fluorine is the highest. For organic chemistry, the order to know is F, then O, then N and Cl, then Br, then C, then H.

Polar bonds

When two different atoms share a pair of electrons, the pair spends more time near the atom with the higher electronegativity. That atom ends up slightly negative, and the other slightly positive. A bond like this is called polar. The small charges are written with the Greek letter delta: δ− on the electron-rich end and δ+ on the electron-poor end.

CHHHCl
Chloromethane, CH3Cl. Chlorine pulls harder than carbon, so chlorine is δ− and carbon is δ+.
Describe this figure

Lewis structure of chloromethane. Carbon has three hydrogens and a single bond to chlorine. Chlorine has a single bond to carbon and three lone pairs.

A second way to show the same thing is a dipole arrow. The arrow points toward the negative end. Its tail has a small cross, like a plus sign, to mark the positive end.

How polar is polar? A rough guide uses the difference in electronegativity.[OpenStax Organic 2.1]

  • Less than 0.5: nearly even sharing. Treat the bond as nonpolar. Carbon–hydrogen bonds are here.
  • From 0.5 to 2: a polar covalent bond. Carbon–oxygen, carbon–chlorine and oxygen–hydrogen bonds are here.
  • More than 2: the electrons are mostly on one atom, and the bond is mostly ionic.

Key idea

A partial charge is not a formal charge. Formal charge is bookkeeping with whole numbers. A partial charge is real, uneven electron density, and it is always less than a full charge.

Now find the polar bonds in a real molecule. Methanol, CH3OH, has three kinds of bond.

CaHHHObHc
Methanol, CH3OH, with three atoms labeled.
Describe this figure

Lewis structure of methanol. Carbon a has three hydrogens and a single bond to oxygen. Oxygen b has one hydrogen, a single bond to carbon, and two lone pairs.

The C–H bonds are close to nonpolar. The C–O bond is polar, with oxygen negative. The O–H bond is even more polar, again with oxygen negative. So oxygen b is δ−, and both carbon a and hydrogen c are δ+. One electron-rich atom sits between two electron-poor ones.

From polar bonds to polar molecules

A molecule is polar if it has a positive end and a negative end overall. To find out, treat each bond dipole as an arrow and add the arrows. Arrows that point in opposite directions cancel. Arrows that point roughly the same way add up.

The size of a molecule’s overall dipole is called its dipole moment. It is measured in a unit called the debye, written D.

Carbon dioxide has two polar C=O bonds. The molecule is linear, so the two arrows point in exactly opposite directions and cancel. Its dipole moment is zero.[OpenStax Organic 2.2]

Loading 3D model of carbon dioxide…

Carbon dioxide. Two bond dipoles, equal and opposite. They cancel.
Describe this model

Carbon dioxide is a straight rod: oxygen, carbon, oxygen. A dipole arrow lies along each carbon–oxygen bond, pointing from carbon out to oxygen. The two arrows point in opposite directions and are the same size, so there is no overall arrow.

Water also has two polar bonds, but water is bent. Both arrows point partly toward the oxygen side, so they add up. Water has a dipole moment of 1.85 D, which is large for such a small molecule.[OpenStax Organic 2.2]

Loading 3D model of water…

Water. The two bond dipoles add up to one overall dipole, drawn beside the molecule.
Describe this model

Water is bent. A dipole arrow lies along each oxygen–hydrogen bond, pointing from hydrogen toward oxygen. Beside the molecule a larger arrow shows the overall dipole. It points from the hydrogen side toward the oxygen side, along the line that cuts the molecule in half.

Key idea

Polar bonds are needed for a polar molecule, but they are not enough. The shape decides whether the bond dipoles cancel.

Same bonds, different shape

Tetrachloromethane, CCl4, has four polar C–Cl bonds. They point to the four corners of a tetrahedron, and four equal arrows arranged that way cancel exactly. The molecule is nonpolar, with a dipole moment of zero.[OpenStax Organic 2.2]

Loading 3D model of tetrachloromethane…

Tetrachloromethane. Four equal bond dipoles pointing to the corners of a tetrahedron cancel.
Describe this model

Tetrachloromethane is a carbon atom with four chlorine atoms at the corners of a tetrahedron. A dipole arrow lies along each bond, pointing out from carbon to chlorine. There is no overall arrow, because the four cancel.

Swap three of the chlorines for hydrogens and you have chloromethane, CH3Cl. Now one strong arrow has nothing to cancel it. Chloromethane is polar, with a dipole moment of 1.87 D.[OpenStax Organic 2.2]

Loading 3D model of chloromethane…

Chloromethane. One carbon–chlorine dipole with nothing to cancel it.
Describe this model

Chloromethane is a carbon atom with three hydrogens and one chlorine around it in a tetrahedron. One dipole arrow lies along the carbon–chlorine bond, pointing toward chlorine. Beside the molecule an overall arrow points the same way.

Shape can even separate two molecules that have the same atoms and the same bonds. In 1,2-dichloroethene, each carbon of a C=C double bond carries one chlorine. The chlorines can be on the same side of the double bond, which is called cis, or on opposite sides, which is called trans.

Loading 3D model of cis-1,2-dichloroethene…

The cis form. Both chlorines are on one side, so the dipoles add.
Describe this model

A flat molecule with a carbon–carbon double bond in the middle. Both chlorine atoms are on the same side of the double bond, and both hydrogens are on the other side. The two carbon–chlorine dipole arrows point toward the same side, and an overall arrow beside the molecule points that way too.

Loading 3D model of trans-1,2-dichloroethene…

The trans form. The chlorines are on opposite sides, so the dipoles cancel.
Describe this model

A flat molecule with a carbon–carbon double bond in the middle. The two chlorine atoms are on opposite sides of the double bond, at opposite corners. The two carbon–chlorine dipole arrows point in opposite directions, and there is no overall arrow.

The cis molecule is polar and the trans molecule is not. They are different compounds with different boiling points, and the only difference between them is shape.

Lone pairs are part of the picture

A lone pair is a clump of negative charge that sticks out on one side of an atom. It adds to the dipole in that direction.

Ammonia shows this well. Each N–H bond is polar toward nitrogen, and the lone pair sits on the nitrogen side too. Everything points the same way, and ammonia has a dipole moment of 1.47 D.[OpenStax Organic 2.2]

Loading 3D model of ammonia…

Ammonia. The bond dipoles and the lone pair all point toward the nitrogen end.
Describe this model

Ammonia is a short pyramid with nitrogen at the top. A lobe on nitrogen shows the lone pair. Dipole arrows along the three bonds point from each hydrogen toward nitrogen. An overall arrow beside the molecule points from the hydrogens toward the nitrogen and its lone pair.

This is why the oxygen of water or methanol, and the nitrogen of ammonia, are the electron-rich places in those molecules. They pull electrons in through their bonds, and they hold lone pairs as well.

Why this matters: opposite charges meet

Most reactions in organic chemistry come down to one event. An electron-rich atom in one molecule is attracted to an electron-poor atom in another, and a new bond forms between them. So before you can predict a reaction, you have to find those atoms.

Formaldehyde, CH2O, is a good first case. Oxygen pulls on the four electrons of the double bond, and the molecule has a large dipole moment of 2.33 D.[OpenStax Organic 2.2] The carbon is strongly δ+.

COHH
Formaldehyde. The highlighted carbon is δ+, and electron-rich molecules attack it there.
Describe this figure

Lewis structure of formaldehyde. Formaldehyde, with the carbon atom highlighted. The carbon is double bonded to oxygen, which has two lone pairs, and single bonded to two hydrogens.

Loading 3D model of formaldehyde…

Formaldehyde. The dipole points from carbon to oxygen.
Describe this model

Formaldehyde is flat, with carbon in the middle. One dipole arrow lies along the carbon–oxygen double bond, pointing toward oxygen. An overall arrow beside the molecule points the same way.

Almost every reaction of a C=O group begins with something electron-rich bonding to that carbon. You will see it dozens of times.

Carbon is not always the positive end. In methyllithium, CH3Li, carbon is bonded to a metal that pulls far less than it does. The carbon is δ−, and it behaves as an electron-rich atom. Reversing the polarity of carbon this way is one of the most useful tricks in the course.

Key idea

Carbon bonded to oxygen, nitrogen or a halogen is δ+. Carbon bonded to a metal is δ−. Find the partial charges first, and the reaction often explains itself.

Key concepts

Electronegativity

How strongly an atom pulls shared electrons. The order to know: F, O, N and Cl, Br, C, H, then metals.

Polar bond

Unequal sharing. The atom that pulls harder is δ−. A dipole arrow points toward the negative end.

Polar molecule

Add the bond dipoles as arrows. If they cancel, the molecule is nonpolar. If they do not, it is polar.

Shape decides

CO2 and CCl4 have polar bonds and no overall dipole. Water, ammonia and chloromethane do have one.

Electron-poor and electron-rich

A δ+ atom attracts electron-rich partners. A δ− atom, or an atom with a lone pair, attracts electron-poor ones.

Practice

0 of 9 solved

Check each answer as you go. If you get stuck, open the hint first, then the text solution.

  1. Q1electronegativityOpen

    Which of these bonds is the most polar?

    Question 1: choose one
    Hint

    The most polar bond joins the atoms with the biggest difference in electronegativity. All four bonds include carbon.

    Text solution
    1. Hydrogen is close to carbon in electronegativity, so C–H is nearly nonpolar.
    2. Nitrogen, oxygen and fluorine pull harder and harder, in that order.
    3. Fluorine is the most electronegative element, so C–F is the most polar.
  2. Q2partial chargeOpen

    In the carbon–bromine bond of bromomethane, CH3Br, which atom is δ+?

    Question 2: choose one
    Hint

    Halogens are more electronegative than carbon.

    Text solution
    1. Bromine pulls the shared electrons harder than carbon does.
    2. Bromine is δ− and carbon is δ+.
  3. Q3partial chargeOpen

    Methyllithium, CH3Li, is shown. What partial charge does each labeled atom carry?

    CaHHHLib
    Describe this figure

    Lewis structure of methyllithium. Carbon a has three hydrogens and a single bond to lithium. Lithium b has a single bond to carbon.

    (a) Carbon a

    Question 3 part a: choose one

    (b) Lithium b

    Question 3 part b: choose one
    Hint

    Lithium is a metal. Compare its electronegativity with carbon's.

    Text solution
    1. Carbon is far more electronegative than lithium.
    2. The shared electrons sit closer to carbon, so carbon is δ− and lithium is δ+.
    3. This is the reverse of carbon's usual role, and it makes the carbon electron-rich.
  4. Q4molecular dipoleOpen

    Which of these molecules has no overall dipole?

    Question 4: choose one
    Hint

    Look for the molecule in which all four bonds on carbon are the same.

    Text solution
    1. All four molecules are tetrahedral at carbon.
    2. Only in CCl4 are the four bond dipoles identical, so only there do they cancel completely.
    3. In the other three, the C–Cl dipoles are not balanced by the C–H bonds.
  5. Q5molecular dipole, shapeOpen

    Carbon dioxide and water each have two polar bonds. Why is water polar while carbon dioxide is not?

    Question 5: choose one
    Hint

    Think about which way the two dipole arrows point in each molecule.

    Text solution
    1. In linear carbon dioxide the two arrows point in opposite directions and cancel.
    2. In bent water both arrows point partly toward the oxygen side, so they add up.
    3. The difference is the shape.
  6. Q6molecular dipole, shapeOpen

    In which form of 1,2-dichloroethene do the two carbon–chlorine bond dipoles cancel?

    Question 6: choose one
    Hint

    In one form the chlorines are at opposite corners of the molecule.

    Text solution
    1. In the trans form the chlorines are on opposite sides of the double bond.
    2. The two C–Cl dipoles point in opposite directions and cancel, so the trans form has no overall dipole.
    3. In the cis form both dipoles lean toward the same side and add up.
  7. Q7partial charge, reactivityOpen

    Acetone, the main ingredient in nail polish remover, is shown. An electron-rich molecule is going to attack it. Which labeled atom does it bond to?

    CHHHCaObCHHH
    Describe this figure

    Lewis structure of acetone. Carbon has three hydrogens and a single bond to carbon. Carbon a has a single bond to carbon, a double bond to oxygen, and a single bond to carbon. Oxygen b has a double bond to carbon and two lone pairs. Carbon has three hydrogens and a single bond to carbon.

    Question 7: choose one
    Hint

    Electron-rich means partly negative. It is attracted to the atom that is partly positive.

    Text solution
    1. Oxygen is more electronegative than carbon, so in the C=O bond oxygen is δ− and carbon a is δ+.
    2. An electron-rich molecule is attracted to the δ+ atom.
    3. It bonds to carbon a.
  8. Q8molecular dipole, dataOpen

    Water has a dipole moment of 1.85 D and ammonia has a dipole moment of 1.47 D. Which molecule is more polar?

    Question 8: choose one
    Hint

    A larger dipole moment means a larger separation of charge.

    Text solution
    1. The dipole moment measures how polar a whole molecule is.
    2. 1.85 D is larger than 1.47 D, so water is more polar than ammonia.
    3. That fits the electronegativities: oxygen pulls harder than nitrogen.
  9. Q9partial chargeOpen

    A carbon–hydrogen bond is usually treated as nonpolar. Why?

    Question 9: choose one
    Hint

    Compare where carbon and hydrogen sit in the electronegativity order.

    Text solution
    1. Carbon and hydrogen differ by only about 0.4 on the electronegativity scale.
    2. With so small a difference the electrons are shared almost evenly.
    3. That is why a molecule made only of carbon and hydrogen, such as methane, is nonpolar.

Sources

  • OpenStax Organic 2.1. McMurry, J. Organic Chemistry: A Tenth Edition, section 2.1, Polar Covalent Bonds and Electronegativity. OpenStax, 2023. https://openstax.org/books/organic-chemistry/pages/2-1-polar-covalent-bonds-and-electronegativity
  • OpenStax Organic 2.2. McMurry, J. Organic Chemistry: A Tenth Edition, section 2.2, Polar Covalent Bonds and Dipole Moments. OpenStax, 2023. https://openstax.org/books/organic-chemistry/pages/2-2-polar-covalent-bonds-and-dipole-moments

How did it go?

Sections read: 0%. Practice: 0 answered.

How was this lesson?