Organic ChemistryAll courses

Chapter 1: Structure and Bonding, lesson 6

Resonance and curved arrows

Some molecules cannot be described by one Lewis structure. Chemists describe them with several, and move between the drawings with curved arrows. Those arrows are the most important notation in organic chemistry, and this is where you learn to use them.

  • About 35 minutes
  • 6 sections
  • 9 practice questions
  • Narrated

After this lesson you can

  • Recognize when one Lewis structure is not enough.
  • Draw curved arrows that turn one resonance structure into another.
  • Check that a resonance structure is legal.
  • Describe the resonance hybrid, and explain why it is not an equilibrium.
  • Decide which resonance structure contributes most.

Warm-up check

Three quick questions on formal charge and octets from lesson 1. You will use both in every step of this lesson.

  1. 1.An oxygen atom in a structure has one bond and three lone pairs. What is its formal charge?

    Question 1: choose one
    See the answer

    6 − 6 − 1 = −1. Neutral oxygen has two bonds and two lone pairs, and this one has traded a bond for a lone pair.

  2. 2.What is the largest number of electrons a carbon atom can have around it?

    See the answer

    Carbon is in the second row. It has four valence orbitals, which hold 8 electrons at most.

  3. 3.A carbon atom has three bonds and no lone pairs. What is its formal charge?

    Question 3: choose one
    See the answer

    4 − 0 − 3 = +1. This is a carbocation, with only six electrons.

When one drawing is not enough

In lesson 1 you found the formal charges in the acetate ion, CH3CO2−. The Lewis structure had a double bond to one oxygen, and a single bond to the other oxygen, which carried the negative charge. But which oxygen should get the double bond? Nothing makes one different from the other, so you can draw it either way.

CHHHCOO−

One way

Double bond to the top oxygen. Charge on the bottom oxygen.

CHHHCO−O

The other way

Double bond to the bottom oxygen. Charge on the top oxygen.

Each drawing makes a prediction. A C=O double bond is about 120 pm long and a C–O single bond is about 135 pm, so acetate should have one short bond and one long one. Experiment says otherwise. The two carbon–oxygen bonds in acetate are exactly the same length, 127 pm, in between a single and a double bond.[OpenStax Organic 2.4]

So neither drawing is right. The real ion is something in between, and the two oxygens are identical. A Lewis structure puts every electron pair either on one atom or between two atoms, and acetate has electrons that are spread over three. The fix is to draw both structures and say that the truth is a blend of them. The drawings are called resonance structures.

Curved arrows move electron pairs

Look at what differs between the two drawings. Every atom is in the same place. Only two electron pairs have moved. Organic chemists show a moving electron pair with a curved arrow.

  • The tail of the arrow starts at the electrons that move: a lone pair or a bond.
  • The head of the arrow points to where those electrons end up: a new bond, or an atom that takes them as a lone pair.

An arrow never starts at a positive charge or at an atom with no electrons to give. Electrons move. Charges are only the result.

From one acetate structure to the other

  1. CHHHCOO−

    Step 1. Start with one structure. The bottom oxygen has three lone pairs and a negative charge. It is electron-rich, so the electrons will move away from it.

  2. CHHHCOO−

    Step 2. Draw the first arrow from a lone pair on the bottom oxygen to the bond between that oxygen and carbon. The lone pair becomes a second bond. But stop and count: carbon would now have five bonds, which is ten electrons. That is never allowed.

  3. CHHHCOO−

    Step 3. So a second pair must leave carbon at the same time. Draw the second arrow from the C=O double bond onto the top oxygen. One of the two bonds becomes a lone pair on that oxygen.

  4. CHHHCO−O

    Step 4. Redraw with the electrons in their new places, then recount the formal charges. The bottom oxygen now has two bonds and two lone pairs: neutral. The top oxygen has one bond and three lone pairs: −1. The total charge is still −1.

Key idea

A curved arrow shows one pair of electrons moving. It starts at the electrons and ends where they go. If an arrow would give an atom more than eight electrons, another arrow has to take a pair away from that atom.

The rules of the game

Resonance structures are different drawings of one molecule. That puts strict limits on what an arrow may do.

  • Atoms never move. Every atom keeps its position and its neighbors.
  • Single bonds never break. Only lone pairs and π bonds move. The σ framework stays as it is.
  • No second-row atom ends up with more than eight electrons.
  • The overall charge does not change.
CHHHCOO

Not legal

The highlighted carbon has five bonds. This is what the first arrow gives if you forget the second.

CCOHHHH

Not resonance

Compared with acetaldehyde, CH3CHO, a hydrogen has moved from carbon to oxygen. An atom moved, so this is a different compound.

Nearly all the resonance you will meet is one of three patterns. Learn to spot them and you will rarely have to hunt for arrows.

The first pattern is a lone pair next to a π bond. Acetate is an example. The lone pair moves in to make a new π bond, and the old π bond moves out onto the far atom.

The second pattern is a positive charge next to a π bond. The allyl cation is the simplest case. Only one arrow is needed: the π bond moves over toward the positive carbon, which has room for it.

Now you try. The allyl cation is CH2=CH–CH2+, and the arrow in the drawing shows the move. Choose the formal charge each labeled carbon has after the electrons have moved.

Try it: the allyl cation

CaCC+bHHHHH
Describe this figure

Lewis structure of the allyl cation, with curved arrows showing electrons about to move. Carbon a has two hydrogens and a double bond to carbon. Carbon has one hydrogen, a double bond to carbon, and a single bond to carbon. Carbon b has two hydrogens, a single bond to carbon, and a formal charge of plus 1. A curved arrow goes from the bond between carbon a and carbon to the bond between carbon and carbon b.

Formal charge on carbon a
Formal charge on carbon b
Show the count

Valence electrons, minus nonbonding electrons, minus bonds:

  • Carbon a: 4 − 0 − 3 = +1
  • Carbon b: 4 − 0 − 4 = 0

The third pattern is a π bond between two atoms of different electronegativity. The π electrons can move onto the atom that pulls harder. Formaldehyde, CH2O, does this.

COHH

Main structure

The arrow moves the π bond onto oxygen.

C+O−HH

Minor structure

Carbon is +1 with six electrons. Oxygen is −1.

Try one more. Nitromethane, CH3NO2, follows the first pattern, as acetate does. Choose the formal charge each labeled oxygen has after the electrons have moved.

Try it: nitromethane

CHHHN+OaO−b
Describe this figure

Lewis structure of nitromethane, with curved arrows showing electrons about to move. Carbon has three hydrogens and a single bond to nitrogen. Nitrogen has a single bond to carbon, a double bond to oxygen, a single bond to oxygen, and a formal charge of plus 1. Oxygen a has a double bond to nitrogen and two lone pairs. Oxygen b has a single bond to nitrogen, three lone pairs, and a formal charge of minus 1. A curved arrow goes from a lone pair on oxygen b to the bond between nitrogen and oxygen b. A curved arrow goes from the bond between nitrogen and oxygen a to oxygen a.

Formal charge on oxygen a
Formal charge on oxygen b
Show the count

Valence electrons, minus nonbonding electrons, minus bonds:

  • Oxygen a: 6 − 6 − 1 = −1
  • Oxygen b: 6 − 4 − 2 = 0

The hybrid is the real molecule

Resonance structures are joined by a double-headed arrow, ↔. Be careful with what it means. It is not the pair of arrows used for an equilibrium. Acetate does not flip back and forth between two forms. There is one ion, it never changes, and it looks like neither drawing.

Think of the color teal. You can describe it as halfway between blue and green. A teal wall is not blue one moment and green the next. It is always teal. Blue and green are just the words you had available.

The real molecule is called the resonance hybrid. For acetate, the hybrid has two identical carbon–oxygen bonds, each about one and a half bonds. Each oxygen carries half of the negative charge. Electrons that are spread over several atoms like this are called delocalized.

Key idea

Resonance structures are not real, and the molecule does not switch between them. Only the hybrid is real. The structures are the pieces we use to describe it.

Lesson 5 gives the reason. The carbon and both oxygens each have a p orbital, and the three overlap to make molecular orbitals that cover all three atoms. A Lewis structure cannot draw a bond shared by three atoms, so it takes two structures to say it.

Not all structures count equally

Acetate’s two structures are mirror images, so they contribute equally. Often the structures are different, and then the hybrid looks more like the better one. Judge them in this order.[OpenStax Organic 2.5]

  • Full octets come first. A structure in which every atom has eight electrons beats one with an atom that has six.
  • Fewer charges are better. A structure with no formal charges beats one that separates a plus from a minus.
  • Charges belong where they are comfortable. A negative charge is better on the more electronegative atom.

Apply these to the two structures of formaldehyde. The main structure has full octets and no charges. The minor one has a carbon with six electrons and two separated charges. The hybrid is mostly the main structure, with a little of the minor one mixed in. That small contribution is another way of saying what lesson 3 said: the carbon of a C=O group is δ+.

The enolate ion is a case you will use constantly in later chapters. Its negative charge is shared between an oxygen and a carbon.

CCO−HHH

Charge on oxygen

The bigger contributor. Oxygen is more electronegative and holds the charge better.

C−COHHH

Charge on carbon

The smaller contributor. Both structures have full octets, so the third rule decides.

The hybrid has most of its negative charge on oxygen and some on the end carbon. Both atoms are electron-rich, and either one can react.

Why resonance matters

Spreading a charge out lowers a molecule’s energy. An ion with a delocalized charge is more stable than a similar ion whose charge is stuck on one atom. This single idea explains a great deal. In chapter 2 it will explain why acetic acid is an acid at all: the acetate ion it leaves behind is stabilized by resonance.

Resonance also changes shape. Look at formamide, the simplest amide. Amides are the links that hold proteins together.

NCOHHH

Main structure

Counting groups on nitrogen gives four, which suggests sp3.

N+CO−HHH

Second structure

Here nitrogen has a double bond and only three groups.

For the nitrogen lone pair to be shared with the C=O group, it has to sit in a p orbital that overlaps the π bond. So the nitrogen in an amide is sp2 and flat, not sp3 and pyramidal. The counting shortcut from lesson 4 has one exception, and this is it.

Key idea

An atom with a lone pair, next to a π bond, is sp2. Its lone pair is in a p orbital and is delocalized. Check for resonance before you count groups.

Key concepts

Resonance structures

Two or more Lewis structures for one molecule. They differ only in where lone pairs and π bonds are drawn.

Curved arrows

Each arrow moves one electron pair. The tail is at the electrons, and the head is where they go.

Legal moves

Atoms stay put. Single bonds stay put. No second-row atom goes over eight electrons. The total charge stays the same.

Three patterns

A lone pair next to a π bond. A positive charge next to a π bond. A π bond between atoms of different electronegativity.

The hybrid

The real molecule is a blend, weighted toward the best structures. It does not flip between them.

Ranking

Full octets first, then fewer charges, then negative charge on the more electronegative atom.

Practice

0 of 9 solved

Check each answer as you go. If you get stuck, open the hint first, then the text solution.

  1. Q1arrowsOpen

    What does one curved arrow represent?

    Question 1: choose one
    Hint

    Think about what a lone pair and a bond have in common.

    Text solution
    1. A curved arrow with a full head shows a pair of electrons moving.
    2. It starts at a lone pair or a bond, which are both electron pairs.
    3. Atoms do not move in resonance, and charges are only the result of where the electrons end up.
  2. Q2arrowsOpen

    Where can the tail of a curved arrow start?

    Question 2: choose one
    Hint

    The tail marks the electrons that are about to move.

    Text solution
    1. The tail must be at a pair of electrons.
    2. That means a lone pair or a bond.
    3. A positive charge is a shortage of electrons, so an arrow can point toward it but never start from it.
  3. Q3legal movesOpen

    Structures A and B are shown. Are they resonance structures of each other?

    ACCOHHHHBCCOHHHH
    Describe these figures

    Structure A. Two Lewis structures with the same formula. Carbon has three hydrogens and a single bond to carbon. Carbon has one hydrogen, a single bond to carbon, and a double bond to oxygen. Oxygen has a double bond to carbon and two lone pairs.

    Structure B. Carbon has two hydrogens and a double bond to carbon. Carbon has one hydrogen, a double bond to carbon, and a single bond to oxygen. Oxygen has one hydrogen, a single bond to carbon, and two lone pairs.

    Question 3: choose one
    Hint

    Compare the atoms bonded to oxygen in A and in B.

    Text solution
    1. In A the oxygen is bonded only to carbon. In B it is also bonded to a hydrogen.
    2. A hydrogen atom has moved from carbon to oxygen.
    3. Resonance structures never differ in where the atoms are, so these are two different compounds.
  4. Q4rankingOpen

    Structures A and B are the two resonance structures of an enolate ion. Which one contributes more to the hybrid?

    ACCO−HHHBC−COHHH
    Describe these figures

    Structure A. Two resonance structures of an enolate ion. Carbon has two hydrogens and a double bond to carbon. Carbon has one hydrogen, a double bond to carbon, and a single bond to oxygen. Oxygen has a single bond to carbon, three lone pairs, and a formal charge of minus 1.

    Structure B. Carbon has two hydrogens, a single bond to carbon, one lone pair, and a formal charge of minus 1. Carbon has one hydrogen, a single bond to carbon, and a double bond to oxygen. Oxygen has a double bond to carbon and two lone pairs.

    Question 4: choose one
    Hint

    Both have full octets and one charge. Look at which atom carries the negative charge.

    Text solution
    1. Both structures have full octets and the same number of charges, so the first two rules do not decide.
    2. In A the negative charge is on oxygen. In B it is on carbon.
    3. Oxygen is more electronegative, so A is the larger contributor.
  5. Q5hybridOpen

    In the acetate ion, how much of the negative charge is on each oxygen atom in the resonance hybrid?

    Question 5: choose one
    Hint

    The two resonance structures are mirror images, so they contribute equally.

    Text solution
    1. Each structure puts the whole charge on a different oxygen.
    2. The two structures contribute equally, so the hybrid averages them.
    3. Each oxygen carries half of the negative charge.
  6. Q6hybrid, dataOpen

    A carbon–oxygen single bond is about 135 pm long and a double bond is about 120 pm. Both carbon–oxygen bonds in acetate are 127 pm. What does that tell you?

    Question 6: choose one
    Hint

    127 pm is between the other two values, and the two bonds are the same.

    Text solution
    1. If acetate were either Lewis structure, it would have one long bond and one short one.
    2. Two equal bonds of in-between length mean that each bond is about one and a half bonds.
    3. The ion is a single hybrid. It does not flip between structures.
  7. Q7legal movesOpen

    A student draws one arrow on acetate, from a lone pair on the negative oxygen to the bond between that oxygen and carbon, and stops. What is wrong with the result?

    Question 7: choose one
    Hint

    Count the bonds on carbon after the new bond forms.

    Text solution
    1. The carbon already had four bonds.
    2. A fifth bond would give it ten electrons, and a second-row atom can never have more than eight.
    3. A second arrow must move the old π bond onto the other oxygen.
  8. Q8rankingOpen

    Formaldehyde can be drawn with a C=O double bond and no charges, or with a C–O single bond, a positive carbon and a negative oxygen. Which is the larger contributor, and why?

    Question 8: choose one
    Hint

    Apply the ranking rules in order. The first rule is about octets.

    Text solution
    1. In the charged structure the carbon has only six electrons.
    2. The uncharged structure gives every atom a full octet and separates no charges.
    3. It wins on the first two rules, so it is the larger contributor.
  9. Q9hybridizationOpen

    Formamide is shown. Taking resonance into account, what is the hybridization of nitrogen a?

    NaCOHHH
    Describe this figure

    Lewis structure of formamide. Nitrogen a has two hydrogens, a single bond to carbon, and one lone pair. Carbon has one hydrogen, a single bond to nitrogen, and a double bond to oxygen. Oxygen has a double bond to carbon and two lone pairs.

    Question 9: choose one
    Hint

    The nitrogen has a lone pair, and it is next to a π bond.

    Text solution
    1. Counting groups would give four, which suggests sp3.
    2. But the nitrogen's lone pair is next to the C=O π bond, so it is delocalized.
    3. To overlap with the π bond, the lone pair must be in a p orbital. That makes the nitrogen sp2 and flat.

Sources

  • OpenStax Organic 2.4. McMurry, J. Organic Chemistry: A Tenth Edition, section 2.4, Resonance. OpenStax, 2023. https://openstax.org/books/organic-chemistry/pages/2-4-resonance
  • OpenStax Organic 2.5. McMurry, J. Organic Chemistry: A Tenth Edition, section 2.5, Rules for Resonance Forms. OpenStax, 2023. https://openstax.org/books/organic-chemistry/pages/2-5-rules-for-resonance-forms

How did it go?

Sections read: 0%. Practice: 0 answered.

How was this lesson?