AP ChemistryAll courses

Unit 7: Equilibrium and Solubility, lesson 1

Dynamic equilibrium

Many reactions never finish. They run forward and backward at once, and they settle into a mixture in which nothing seems to change. This lesson is about what is really going on in that mixture.

  • About 15 minutes
  • 6 sections
  • 10 practice questions
  • Narrated

After this lesson you can

  • Say what a reversible reaction is, and read the double arrow.
  • Explain, using rates, how a reaction reaches equilibrium.
  • Explain why equilibrium is called dynamic.
  • Tell from a graph when a reaction has reached equilibrium.
  • State what is equal and what is constant at equilibrium, and what does not have to be equal.

Warm-up check

Three quick questions on ideas this lesson uses. They are not scored.

  1. 1.A reaction is first order in A. As A is used up, the rate of the reaction …

    Question 1: choose one
    See the answer

    The rate is proportional to [A]. Less A means a slower reaction.

  2. 2.On a graph of concentration against time, a flat line means the concentration is …

    Question 2: choose one
    See the answer

    A flat line has zero slope, so the concentration is constant. It does not have to be zero.

  3. 3.Water is being poured into a sink at the same rate that water drains out. The water level …

    Question 3: choose one
    See the answer

    Water in equals water out, so the level holds steady while water keeps moving through.

Reactions that run both ways

In Unit 6, every reaction ran one way. Reactants turned into products until a reactant ran out. Many reactions are not like that. Their products can react with each other and turn back into reactants. A reaction that can run in both directions is called a reversible reaction.

A good example is a colorless gas called dinitrogen tetroxide, N2O4. Each molecule can split into two molecules of nitrogen dioxide, NO2, which is a brown gas. Two molecules of nitrogen dioxide can also join back together.[OpenStax Chemistry 13.1]

N2O4(g) ⇌ 2 NO2(g)

The double arrow says that both directions happen. Reading left to right gives the forward reaction. Reading right to left gives the reverse reaction.

Seal some colorless dinitrogen tetroxide in a glass tube and watch. The gas slowly turns brown as nitrogen dioxide forms. Then the color stops getting darker. It never becomes as dark as pure nitrogen dioxide would be. Both gases are still in the tube, and they stay there.[OpenStax Chemistry 13.1]

Two rates that meet

Why does the color stop changing? The answer comes from rates.

Take the simplest reversible reaction. A turns into B, and B turns back into A. Start with only A. At first the forward reaction is fast, because there is plenty of A. The reverse reaction cannot happen at all, because there is no B yet.

As time passes, A is used up, so the forward reaction slows down. B builds up, so the reverse reaction speeds up. One rate is falling and the other is rising. They must meet.

Forward and reverse rates against timeTwo curves on the same axes. The forward rate starts high, at 0.060 molar per second, and falls. The reverse rate starts at zero and rises. The two curves come together at 0.024 molar per second after about 40 seconds, and from then on they run along the same flat line.01020304050600.000.020.040.06equilibriumforwardreversetime (s)rate (M/s)
The forward rate falls and the reverse rate rises until they are equal.
Describe this graph

Two curves on the same axes. The forward rate starts high, at 0.060 molar per second, and falls. The reverse rate starts at zero and rises. The two curves come together at 0.024 molar per second after about 40 seconds, and from then on they run along the same flat line.

Once the two rates are equal, A is being made exactly as fast as it is being used. The same is true for B. So neither concentration changes any more. This state is called chemical equilibrium.

Key idea

At equilibrium, the rate of the forward reaction equals the rate of the reverse reaction. Because of that, the concentrations stop changing.

Watch it happen

The box below holds 150 particles. Circles are A and squares are B. Any A can turn into a B, and any B can turn back. A particle flashes when it changes. The graph under the box counts the particles as time passes.

Press Start, and watch two things: the lines on the graph, and the flashes in the box.

Start with

Press Start. Circles are A and squares are B.

A reversible reaction, A ⇌ B. Try all three starting mixtures.
Describe this figure

A box holding 150 moving particles. Circles are A and squares are B. Any A can turn into a B, and any B can turn back into an A; a particle flashes yellow when it changes. Keys choose whether the box starts with only A, only B, or half of each. Under the box, a graph draws the number of A particles as a solid line and the number of B particles as a dashed line against time. Whatever the start, the lines level off near 60 A and 90 B after about 40 seconds. A readout counts the changes in each direction over the last 10 seconds. Once the lines are level, the two counts are about equal, and they are not zero.

The lines level off, but the flashing never stops. Read the last line under the graph. Once the lines are level, about as many particles change from A to B as change from B to A. Each change one way is cancelled by a change the other way.

The lines wobble a little because the box holds only 150 particles, so a few chance changes show. A real sample holds so many particles that its lines are perfectly smooth.

This is why chemists call it dynamic equilibrium. Dynamic means moving. Both reactions keep running. Only the totals stay the same.

Try it: what the box shows

After the lines level off, particles in the box
At equilibrium in this box, the numbers of A and B are
Start with only B instead of only A. The final mixture is
Show the reasoning
  • After the lines level off, particles in the box: keep changing in both directions. The flashes go on. Changes each way happen at the same rate, so the counts hold steady.
  • At equilibrium in this box, the numbers of A and B are: steady, but not equal. The box settles near 60 A and 90 B, give or take a few. Steady does not mean equal.
  • Start with only B instead of only A. The final mixture is: about the same as before. The same mixture is reached from either side.

Constant is not the same as equal

Here is the most common mistake in this unit. At equilibrium the rates are equal. The concentrations are not. They are constant, which means they have stopped changing. They can stop at very different values.

In our example, A levels off at 0.40 M and B levels off at 0.60 M. Some reactions stop with almost no reactant left. Others stop with almost no product. Lesson 4 shows how to tell which.

The graph below also shows something you saw in the box. Use the keys to start with only A, and then with only B.

Start with
Concentrations against time, starting with only AConcentration against time, starting with only A. The curve for A falls from 1.0 molar and levels off at 0.40 molar. The curve for B rises from zero and levels off at 0.60 molar. The curves cross early on, keep changing, and are both flat after about 40 seconds. They are flat at different heights.01020304050600.00.20.40.60.81.0equilibrium[A][B]time (s)concentration (M)

Starting with only A: the mixture ends at 0.40 M A and 0.60 M B.

The same reaction, started from each side.
Describe this figure

Concentration against time, starting with only A. The curve for A falls from 1.0 molar and levels off at 0.40 molar. The curve for B rises from zero and levels off at 0.60 molar. The curves cross early on, keep changing, and are both flat after about 40 seconds. They are flat at different heights. Starting with only A: the mixture ends at 0.40 M A and 0.60 M B.

Concentration against time, starting with only B. The curve for B falls from 1.0 molar and levels off at 0.60 molar. The curve for A rises from zero and levels off at 0.40 molar. Both are flat after about 40 seconds, at the same heights as in the experiment that started with only A. Starting with only B: the mixture ends at the same 0.40 M A and 0.60 M B.

The curves look different, but they end at the same place. At a given temperature, a reaction reaches the same equilibrium mixture whether you start with the reactants or with the products.

Key idea

Equal rates, constant concentrations. The concentrations of reactants and products do not have to be equal to each other.

Finding equilibrium on a graph

On a graph of concentration against time, equilibrium is where every curve goes flat. Before that, the curves are still rising or falling, so the reaction has not reached equilibrium yet.

Two warnings. The point where two curves cross is not equilibrium. The concentrations happen to be equal there, but they are still changing. Also, the curves do not have to cross at all.

On a graph of rate against time, equilibrium is where the forward and reverse curves meet and become one flat line. Notice that this line is not at zero. Both reactions are still running.

Try it: reading the graphs

Use the two graphs above, for the reaction that starts with only A.

The curves for A and B cross at about 18 seconds. Is the reaction at equilibrium there?
At 50 seconds, the forward rate is
At 10 seconds, which rate is greater?
Show the reasoning
  • The curves for A and B cross at about 18 seconds. Is the reaction at equilibrium there?: no. Both curves are still changing at 18 seconds. They go flat near 40 seconds.
  • At 50 seconds, the forward rate is: equal to the reverse rate. The two rate curves have merged at 0.024 M/s. Equal, and not zero.
  • At 10 seconds, which rate is greater?: forward. A is still falling, so A is being used faster than it is being made.

What equilibrium needs

Equilibrium can only be reached in a closed system. That means nothing can enter or leave. If a product escapes, the reverse reaction has nothing to work with, and the reaction keeps running forward. An open bottle of soda goes flat for this reason. The carbon dioxide gas leaves and never comes back.

Equilibrium is not only for chemical reactions. Put a little water in a bottle and close it. Water evaporates, and water vapor condenses back. When those two rates are equal, the amount of liquid stops changing. Phase changes and dissolving reach equilibrium in the same way.[OpenStax Chemistry 13.1]

From the outside, a system at equilibrium looks finished. Its color, its pressure and its concentrations hold steady. Underneath, both reactions are running as fast as each other.

Key concepts

Reversible reaction

A reaction that runs in both directions. It is written with a double arrow.

Chemical equilibrium

The state in which the forward and reverse rates are equal, so concentrations stay constant.

Dynamic

Both reactions keep going at equilibrium. Neither rate is zero.

Constant, not equal

Concentrations stop changing at equilibrium. They are usually not equal to each other.

Either direction

The same equilibrium mixture is reached from the reactants or from the products, at the same temperature.

Closed system

Nothing enters or leaves. Equilibrium needs one.

Practice

0 of 10 solved

Check each answer as you go. If you get stuck, open the hint first, then the text solution.

  1. Q1definitionOpen

    Which statement is always true for a reaction at equilibrium?

    Question 1: choose one
    Hint

    One thing is equal at equilibrium. It is not the concentrations.

    Text solution
    1. Equilibrium is defined by rates: the forward rate equals the reverse rate.
    2. The concentrations are constant, but they do not have to be equal.
    3. Both reactions are still running.
  2. Q2dynamicOpen

    Why is chemical equilibrium described as dynamic?

    Question 2: choose one
    Hint

    Think of the flashes in the particle box after the lines went flat.

    Text solution
    1. Dynamic means moving.
    2. At equilibrium, reactant is still turning into product and product is still turning back.
    3. The two rates are equal, so the amounts do not change.
  3. Q3ratesOpen

    A reversible reaction is started with only reactants. As it moves toward equilibrium, what happens to each rate?

    (a) Forward rate

    Question 3 part a: choose one

    (b) Reverse rate

    Question 3 part b: choose one
    Hint

    Which concentration is falling, and which is rising?

    Text solution
    1. Reactants are used up, so the forward rate decreases.
    2. Products build up, so the reverse rate increases.
    3. The two rates change until they are equal.
  4. Q4graphOpen

    The graph shows X turning into Y in a closed container. At which marked point is the reaction at equilibrium?

    Concentrations of X and Y against timeConcentration against time for a reaction in which X turns into Y. The curve for X falls from 0.8 molar and levels off at 0.35 molar. The curve for Y rises from zero and levels off at 0.45 molar. Three points are marked on the X curve: P at 5 seconds, where the curve is falling steeply; Q at 12 seconds, where it is still falling; and R at 40 seconds, where it is flat.010203040500.00.20.40.60.8[X][Y]PQRtime (s)concentration (M)
    Describe this figure

    Concentration against time for a reaction in which X turns into Y. The curve for X falls from 0.8 molar and levels off at 0.35 molar. The curve for Y rises from zero and levels off at 0.45 molar. Three points are marked on the X curve: P at 5 seconds, where the curve is falling steeply; Q at 12 seconds, where it is still falling; and R at 40 seconds, where it is flat.

    Question 4: choose one
    Hint

    Look for where the curves are flat.

    Text solution
    1. At P and Q the curve for X is still falling, so concentrations are still changing.
    2. At R both curves are flat.
    3. Constant concentrations mean the reaction is at equilibrium at R.
  5. Q5graph, constant not equalOpen

    Use the same graph. The curves for X and Y cross at about 14 seconds. A student says the reaction is at equilibrium there because [X] = [Y]. Is the student correct?

    Concentrations of X and Y against timeConcentration against time for a reaction in which X turns into Y. The curve for X falls from 0.8 molar and levels off at 0.35 molar. The curve for Y rises from zero and levels off at 0.45 molar. Three points are marked on the X curve: P at 5 seconds, where the curve is falling steeply; Q at 12 seconds, where it is still falling; and R at 40 seconds, where it is flat.010203040500.00.20.40.60.8[X][Y]PQRtime (s)concentration (M)
    Describe this figure

    Concentration against time for a reaction in which X turns into Y. The curve for X falls from 0.8 molar and levels off at 0.35 molar. The curve for Y rises from zero and levels off at 0.45 molar. Three points are marked on the X curve: P at 5 seconds, where the curve is falling steeply; Q at 12 seconds, where it is still falling; and R at 40 seconds, where it is flat.

    Question 5: choose one
    Hint

    What does equilibrium require of the concentrations: equal, or constant?

    Text solution
    1. Equilibrium means constant concentrations, not equal ones.
    2. At 14 seconds both curves are still changing.
    3. The curves go flat later, with [X] at 0.35 M and [Y] at 0.45 M.
  6. Q6rates, graphOpen

    Use the same graph. At point Q, how does the forward rate compare with the reverse rate?

    Concentrations of X and Y against timeConcentration against time for a reaction in which X turns into Y. The curve for X falls from 0.8 molar and levels off at 0.35 molar. The curve for Y rises from zero and levels off at 0.45 molar. Three points are marked on the X curve: P at 5 seconds, where the curve is falling steeply; Q at 12 seconds, where it is still falling; and R at 40 seconds, where it is flat.010203040500.00.20.40.60.8[X][Y]PQRtime (s)concentration (M)
    Describe this figure

    Concentration against time for a reaction in which X turns into Y. The curve for X falls from 0.8 molar and levels off at 0.35 molar. The curve for Y rises from zero and levels off at 0.45 molar. Three points are marked on the X curve: P at 5 seconds, where the curve is falling steeply; Q at 12 seconds, where it is still falling; and R at 40 seconds, where it is flat.

    Question 6: choose one
    Hint

    Is [X] going down, going up or holding steady at Q?

    Text solution
    1. At Q the concentration of X is still falling.
    2. So X is being used up faster than it is being re-formed.
    3. The forward rate is greater than the reverse rate.
  7. Q7either directionOpen

    At a fixed temperature, flask 1 is filled with pure N2O4 and flask 2 with pure NO2. The flasks hold the same number of nitrogen and oxygen atoms and have the same volume. After both reach equilibrium, how do the mixtures compare?

    Question 7: choose one
    Hint

    Remember the Only A and Only B keys.

    Text solution
    1. The reaction N2O4 ⇌ 2 NO2 can be approached from either side.
    2. With the same atoms, volume and temperature, both flasks end with the same concentrations.
    3. The starting side does not matter.
  8. Q8closed systemOpen

    Solid calcium carbonate is heated in an open dish. It breaks down into solid calcium oxide and carbon dioxide gas, and it keeps breaking down until none is left. Why does this reaction not reach equilibrium?

    Question 8: choose one
    Hint

    Is the dish a closed system?

    Text solution
    1. Equilibrium needs a closed system.
    2. In an open dish the carbon dioxide leaves.
    3. Without carbon dioxide the reverse reaction cannot happen, so the forward reaction runs until the solid is gone.
  9. Q9rates, calculationOpen

    For A ⇌ B, the forward rate is 0.060 M/s at the start, when only A is present. Later, at equilibrium, the forward rate is 0.024 M/s. What is the reverse rate at equilibrium?

    Hint

    What is true of the two rates at equilibrium?

    Text solution
    1. At equilibrium the forward and reverse rates are equal.
    2. The forward rate at equilibrium is 0.024 M/s.
    3. So the reverse rate is 0.024 M/s. It is not zero.
  10. Q10observationOpen

    A sealed tube of N2O4 and NO2 has had the same brown color for an hour. Which conclusion is best?

    Question 10: choose one
    Hint

    Constant color means constant concentration of the brown gas.

    Text solution
    1. A steady color means [NO2] is constant.
    2. Constant concentrations in a closed tube mean equilibrium.
    3. At equilibrium, N2O4 is still splitting and NO2 is still joining, at equal rates.

Sources

  • OpenStax Chemistry 13.1. Flowers, P.; Theopold, K.; Langley, R.; Robinson, W. R. Chemistry 2e, section 13.1, Chemical Equilibria. OpenStax, 2019. https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/13-1-chemical-equilibria

How did it go?

Sections read: 0%. Practice: 0 answered.

How was this lesson?