AP ChemistryAll courses

Unit 7: Equilibrium and Solubility, lesson 8

The 5% rule and the quadratic formula

Lesson 7 dropped x from a subtraction to make the algebra easy. That shortcut is not always safe. This lesson gives a test for it, and a way to solve the problem when the test fails. It goes beyond what the AP exam asks you to calculate.

  • About 20 minutes
  • 5 sections
  • 7 practice questions
  • Narrated
  • Beyond the test

After this lesson you can

  • State the 5 percent rule and use it to check the small-x shortcut.
  • Predict from K and the starting concentration whether the shortcut is likely to work.
  • Rearrange an equilibrium equation into the form ax2 + bx + c = 0.
  • Solve it with the quadratic formula and choose the root that makes sense.

Warm-up check

Three quick questions on ideas this lesson uses. They are not scored.

  1. 1.What is 0.0030 as a percentage of 0.060?

    See the answer

    (0.0030 ÷ 0.060) × 100 = 5.0.

  2. 2.A very small K means that, at equilibrium, the mixture is mostly …

    Question 2: choose one
    See the answer

    Small K means reactants are favored, so little reactant is used up.

  3. 3.What is √0.0049?

    See the answer

    0.070 × 0.070 = 0.0049.

The shortcut and its risk

In lesson 7, a term like 0.50 − x was replaced by 0.50, on the grounds that x was tiny. That turned a hard equation into an easy one.

The shortcut changes the answer a little. If x really is tiny, the change is too small to matter. If x is not tiny, the answer can be badly wrong. So the shortcut always needs a check afterward.[OpenStax Chemistry 13.4]

The 5 percent rule

The usual test is this. After solving with the shortcut, compare x with the starting concentration it was dropped from.

percent change = (x ÷ initial concentration) × 100

If the result is less than 5 percent, the shortcut is accepted. If it is more than 5 percent, the shortcut is rejected, and the equation has to be solved in full.

The number 5 is a convention. It reflects the fact that most K values are only known to two significant figures, so an error of a few percent is no worse than the data.

A case that passes

  1. Step 1. The problem. For A ⇌ B + C, K = 1.0 × 10−6. A flask starts with 0.040 M A.

  2. Step 2. Set up and use the shortcut. K = x2 ÷ (0.040 − x). Drop the x on the bottom: x2 = (1.0 × 10−6)(0.040) = 4.0 × 10−8, so x = 2.0 × 10−4 M.

  3. Step 3. Check. (2.0 × 10−4 ÷ 0.040) × 100 = 0.50 percent. That is far below 5, so the shortcut is fine.

A case that fails

  1. Step 1. The problem. For A ⇌ B + C, K = 0.010. A flask starts with 0.10 M A.

  2. Step 2. Try the shortcut. x2 = (0.010)(0.10) = 0.0010, so x = 0.032 M.

  3. Step 3. Check. (0.032 ÷ 0.10) × 100 = 32 percent. That is far above 5. Nearly a third of the A has reacted, so 0.10 − x is nothing like 0.10. The shortcut is rejected.

Predicting before you start

You can often tell in advance. The shortcut works when K is small and the starting concentration is large. For a reaction of the form A ⇌ B + C, a handy guide is to divide the starting concentration by K.

  • If the result is greater than about 400, the shortcut will pass.
  • If it is less, expect to need the full solution.

In the first case above, 0.040 ÷ (1.0 × 10−6) is 40,000, so it passes easily. In the second, 0.10 ÷ 0.010 is only 10, so it fails.

Try it: is the shortcut safe?

x = 0.0020 M and the initial concentration is 0.10 M. Percent change
Is the shortcut acceptable there?
x = 0.012 M and the initial concentration is 0.15 M. Acceptable?
Show the reasoning
  • x = 0.0020 M and the initial concentration is 0.10 M. Percent change: 2 percent. (0.0020 ÷ 0.10) × 100 = 2 percent
  • Is the shortcut acceptable there?: yes. 2 percent is less than 5 percent.
  • x = 0.012 M and the initial concentration is 0.15 M. Acceptable?: no. (0.012 ÷ 0.15) × 100 = 8 percent, which is more than 5.

Solving in full: the quadratic formula

When the shortcut fails, keep the x. For many reactions the equation is then a quadratic, which means the highest power of x is x2. Any quadratic can be arranged like this.

ax2 + bx + c = 0

Its solutions come from the quadratic formula.

x = (−b ± √(b2 − 4ac)) ÷ 2a

The failed case, solved in full

  1. Step 1. Start from the full equation. 0.010 = x2 ÷ (0.10 − x)

  2. Step 2. Multiply both sides by the bottom. 0.010(0.10 − x) = x2, which is 0.0010 − 0.010x = x2.

  3. Step 3. Move everything to one side. x2 + 0.010x − 0.0010 = 0. So a = 1, b = 0.010 and c = −0.0010.

  4. Step 4. Use the formula. b2 − 4ac = 0.00010 + 0.0040 = 0.0041, and its square root is 0.0640. So x = (−0.010 ± 0.0640) ÷ 2.

  5. Step 5. Choose the root that makes sense. The two answers are x = 0.027 and x = −0.037. A concentration cannot be negative, so x = 0.027 M.

  6. Step 6. Finish and check. [B] = [C] = 0.027 M and [A] = 0.10 − 0.027 = 0.073 M. Check: (0.027)2 ÷ 0.073 = 0.010. It matches K.

Compare the two answers. The shortcut gave 0.032 M and the full solution gives 0.027 M. The shortcut was off by nearly a fifth.

A quadratic always gives two roots. Only one of them is physically possible. Reject any root that makes a concentration negative, or that uses up more of a reactant than there was to begin with.

What the AP exam expects

The AP exam does not require the quadratic formula. Its problems are chosen so that the equation is a perfect square or the small-x shortcut is clearly fair. You should still know why the shortcut works: when K is very small, very little reactant is used up.

Key concepts

5 percent rule

The small-x shortcut is accepted if x is less than 5 percent of the concentration it was dropped from.

Predicting

Small K and a large starting concentration make the shortcut safe.

Quadratic formula

x = (−b ± √(b2 − 4ac)) ÷ 2a, for ax2 + bx + c = 0.

Choosing a root

Keep the root that gives no negative concentrations.

Practice

0 of 7 solved

Check each answer as you go. If you get stuck, open the hint first, then the text solution.

  1. Q1checkOpen

    A small-x calculation gives x = 0.0040 M. The initial concentration was 0.20 M. What is x as a percentage of the initial concentration?

    Hint

    (x ÷ initial) × 100.

    Text solution
    1. (0.0040 ÷ 0.20) × 100.
    2. = 2.0 percent.
  2. Q2checkOpen

    A small-x calculation gives x = 0.018 M when the initial concentration was 0.12 M. Is the shortcut acceptable?

    Question 2: choose one
    Hint

    Work out the percentage.

    Text solution
    1. (0.018 ÷ 0.12) × 100 = 15 percent.
    2. That is more than 5 percent.
    3. The shortcut is not acceptable.
  3. Q3predictOpen

    For reactions of the form A ⇌ B + C, in which case is the small-x shortcut most likely to be safe?

    Question 3: choose one
    Hint

    The shortcut needs a small K and a large starting concentration.

    Text solution
    1. Divide the starting concentration by K.
    2. 0.50 ÷ (1 × 10−9) is enormous, far above 400.
    3. The other two give 2.5 and 0.5.
  4. Q4shortcutOpen

    For A ⇌ B + C, K = 9.0 × 10−8. A flask starts with 0.10 M A. Use the shortcut to find x, in M.

    Hint

    x2 = K × 0.10.

    Text solution
    1. x2 = (9.0 × 10−8)(0.10) = 9.0 × 10−9.
    2. x = 9.5 × 10−5 M.
    3. Check: that is about 0.1 percent of 0.10 M, so the shortcut is fine.
  5. Q5quadraticOpen

    For A ⇌ B + C, K = 0.050. A flask starts with 0.20 M A. The shortcut fails. Solve x2 + 0.050x − 0.010 = 0 for x, in M.

    Hint

    a = 1, b = 0.050, c = −0.010. Take the positive root.

    Text solution
    1. b2 − 4ac = 0.0025 + 0.040 = 0.0425, and √0.0425 = 0.2062.
    2. x = (−0.050 + 0.2062) ÷ 2.
    3. x = 0.078 M.
  6. Q6rootsOpen

    A quadratic gives x = 0.045 M and x = −0.095 M for a reaction that starts with only reactants. Which root is correct, and why?

    Question 6: choose one
    Hint

    The products start at zero and have a concentration of x at equilibrium.

    Text solution
    1. The products have concentration x at equilibrium.
    2. A concentration cannot be negative.
    3. x = 0.045 M.
  7. Q7conceptOpen

    Why is an error of a few percent from the small-x shortcut usually acceptable?

    Question 7: choose one
    Hint

    Think about how well K itself is known.

    Text solution
    1. An answer cannot be more precise than the data it comes from.
    2. With K known to two significant figures, a few percent of error is no worse than the data.

Sources

  • OpenStax Chemistry 13.4. Flowers, P.; Theopold, K.; Langley, R.; Robinson, W. R. Chemistry 2e, section 13.4, Equilibrium Calculations. OpenStax, 2019. https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/13-4-equilibrium-calculations

How did it go?

Sections read: 0%. Practice: 0 answered.

How was this lesson?