AP ChemistryAll courses

Unit 7: Equilibrium and Solubility, lesson 13

Separating ions by selective precipitation

Different solids start to precipitate at different concentrations. By adding a reagent slowly, a chemist can pull one ion out of a mixture as a solid while another stays dissolved.

  • About 15 minutes
  • 5 sections
  • 7 practice questions
  • Narrated

After this lesson you can

  • Calculate the concentration at which each of two solids begins to precipitate.
  • Decide which solid precipitates first.
  • Find how much of the first ion is left when the second solid begins to form.
  • Judge whether two ions can be separated well.

Warm-up check

Three quick questions on ideas this lesson uses. They are not scored.

  1. 1.A precipitate just begins to form when …

    Question 1: choose one
    See the answer

    Below Ksp the solution is unsaturated. Solid appears once Q reaches Ksp.

  2. 2.Ksp for AgCl is 1.6 × 10−10. In a solution with [Cl−] = 0.10 M, what [Ag+] makes Q equal to Ksp, in M?

    See the answer

    [Ag+] = (1.6 × 10−10) ÷ 0.10 = 1.6 × 10−9 M.

  3. 3.Which number is smaller?

    Question 3: choose one
    See the answer

    10−14 is a million times smaller than 10−8.

The idea

Suppose a solution contains two different ions, and you want to separate them. One way is to add something that forms a solid with both, but at very different concentrations. The solid that needs less of the added ion forms first. If you stop adding at the right moment and filter, one ion is in the solid and the other is still in the solution. This is called selective precipitation.[OpenStax Chemistry 15.1]

The tool is the calculation from the end of lesson 12. For each solid, set Q equal to Ksp and find the concentration of the added ion at which that solid just begins to form.

Chloride and iodide

A solution contains 0.010 M Cl− and 0.010 M I−. Silver ions are added slowly, as a solution of silver nitrate. Both AgCl and AgI are only slightly soluble. Their Ksp values are 1.6 × 10−10 and 1.5 × 10−16.[OpenStax Chemistry, Appendix J]

Which solid forms first?

  1. Step 1. Find the silver concentration that starts AgI. [Ag+] = Ksp ÷ [I−] = (1.5 × 10−16) ÷ 0.010 = 1.5 × 10−14 M

  2. Step 2. Find the silver concentration that starts AgCl. [Ag+] = Ksp ÷ [Cl−] = (1.6 × 10−10) ÷ 0.010 = 1.6 × 10−8 M

  3. Step 3. Compare. AgI needs far less silver, so AgI precipitates first. It begins when [Ag+] reaches 1.5 × 10−14 M.

  4. Step 4. Keep adding. As more silver goes in, more AgI forms and [I−] falls. AgCl does not begin until [Ag+] has climbed all the way to 1.6 × 10−8 M.

Key idea

The solid that needs the lowest concentration of the added ion precipitates first.

How clean is the separation?

The useful question is how much iodide is still dissolved at the moment silver chloride starts to form. At that moment [Ag+] is 1.6 × 10−8 M, and the solution is still saturated with AgI. So the iodide left must satisfy the Ksp of AgI.

[I−] = Ksp(AgI) ÷ [Ag+] = (1.5 × 10−16) ÷ (1.6 × 10−8) = 9.4 × 10−9 M

The iodide started at 0.010 M. Less than one millionth of it is left in the solution when the first speck of AgCl appears. That is an excellent separation. Filter at that point, and nearly all the iodide is in the solid while all the chloride is still dissolved.

A separation works well when the two starting concentrations of the added ion are far apart, as they are here. If they are close together, the second solid starts to form while much of the first ion is still in solution, and the solids come out mixed.

When the formulas differ

For AgCl and AgI, the solid with the smaller Ksp came out first. That shortcut only works when the two solids have the same ion ratio and the two ions start at the same concentration. Otherwise you have to calculate.

A solution contains 0.010 M Cl− and 0.010 M CrO42−. Silver ions are added. The Ksp of Ag2CrO4 is 9.0 × 10−12, which is smaller than the value for AgCl.[OpenStax Chemistry, Appendix J]

AgCl begins at [Ag+] = (1.6 × 10−10) ÷ 0.010 = 1.6 × 10−8 M.   Ag2CrO4 begins at [Ag+]2 = (9.0 × 10−12) ÷ 0.010, so [Ag+] = 3.0 × 10−5 M.

Silver chloride forms first, even though its Ksp is the larger of the two. The silver concentration is squared in the expression for silver chromate, and that changes the answer.

Try it: which comes first?

A solution has 0.010 M Br− and 0.010 M Cl−. Ag+ is added slowly. Ksp: AgBr 5.0 × 10−13, AgCl 1.6 × 10−10.

[Ag+] at which AgBr begins
Which solid precipitates first?
[Br−] left when AgCl begins
Show the reasoning
  • [Ag+] at which AgBr begins: 5.0 × 10−11 M. (5.0 × 10−13) ÷ 0.010 = 5.0 × 10−11 M
  • Which solid precipitates first?: AgBr. AgBr needs 5.0 × 10−11 M Ag+. AgCl needs 1.6 × 10−8 M, which is much more.
  • [Br−] left when AgCl begins: 3.1 × 10−5 M. (5.0 × 10−13) ÷ (1.6 × 10−8) = 3.1 × 10−5 M

Where this is used

Selective precipitation is one of the oldest tools in chemistry. It is used to find out which metal ions are in an unknown solution, by adding reagents in a set order and seeing what comes out at each stage. It is also used on a large scale to remove toxic metal ions from waste water, and to recover valuable metals from ores.

Key concepts

Selective precipitation

Separating ions by adding a reagent that makes one solid form before another.

Which comes first

The solid that begins to form at the lowest concentration of the added ion.

What is left

When the second solid begins, the first ion’s concentration is its Ksp divided by the added ion’s concentration at that moment.

A good separation

Needs the two starting points to be far apart.

Caution

The smaller Ksp comes first only when the solids have the same ion ratio and the ions start equal.

Practice

0 of 7 solved

Check each answer as you go. If you get stuck, open the hint first, then the text solution.

  1. Q1firstOpen

    A solution contains 0.010 M Ba2+ and 0.010 M Ca2+. Sulfate is added slowly. Ksp: BaSO4 2.3 × 10−8, CaSO4 6.1 × 10−5. Which solid precipitates first?

    Question 1: choose one
    Hint

    Find the sulfate concentration needed for each.

    Text solution
    1. BaSO4 begins at [SO42−] = (2.3 × 10−8) ÷ 0.010 = 2.3 × 10−6 M.
    2. CaSO4 begins at [SO42−] = (6.1 × 10−5) ÷ 0.010 = 6.1 × 10−3 M.
    3. BaSO4 needs less sulfate, so it forms first.
  2. Q2beginsOpen

    For the same solution, at what [SO42−] does CaSO4 begin to precipitate, in M?

    Hint

    [SO42−] = Ksp ÷ [Ca2+].

    Text solution
    1. [SO42−] = (6.1 × 10−5) ÷ 0.010.
    2. [SO42−] = 6.1 × 10−3 M.
  3. Q3leftOpen

    For the same solution, what is [Ba2+] at the moment CaSO4 begins to precipitate, in M?

    Hint

    At that moment [SO42−] = 6.1 × 10−3 M, and the solution is saturated with BaSO4.

    Text solution
    1. [Ba2+] = Ksp(BaSO4) ÷ [SO42−].
    2. [Ba2+] = (2.3 × 10−8) ÷ (6.1 × 10−3).
    3. [Ba2+] = 3.8 × 10−6 M.
  4. Q4different formsOpen

    A solution contains 0.010 M Ag+ and 0.010 M Pb2+. Chloride is added slowly. Ksp: AgCl 1.6 × 10−10, PbCl2 1.6 × 10−5. At what [Cl−] does PbCl2 begin to precipitate, in M?

    Hint

    [Cl−]2 = Ksp ÷ [Pb2+].

    Text solution
    1. [Cl−]2 = (1.6 × 10−5) ÷ 0.010 = 1.6 × 10−3.
    2. [Cl−] = √(1.6 × 10−3).
    3. [Cl−] = 0.040 M.
  5. Q5firstOpen

    In the solution from the last question, AgCl begins at [Cl−] = 1.6 × 10−8 M and PbCl2 at 0.040 M. Which statement is correct?

    Question 5: choose one
    Hint

    Compare the two starting points.

    Text solution
    1. AgCl needs far less chloride, so it forms first.
    2. The two starting points are more than a million times apart.
    3. Nearly all the silver is removed before any lead chloride forms.
  6. Q6conceptOpen

    What makes two ions easy to separate by selective precipitation?

    Question 6: choose one
    Hint

    Think about how much of the first ion is left when the second solid starts.

    Text solution
    1. If the starting points are far apart, almost all of the first ion has precipitated before the second solid begins.
    2. If they are close, the solids come out mixed.
  7. Q7cautionOpen

    A solution has equal concentrations of Cl− and CrO42−. Ag2CrO4 has a smaller Ksp than AgCl, but AgCl precipitates first when Ag+ is added. Why?

    Question 7: choose one
    Hint

    Write both Ksp expressions.

    Text solution
    1. Ksp(AgCl) = [Ag+][Cl−], but Ksp(Ag2CrO4) = [Ag+]2[CrO42−].
    2. Solving each for [Ag+] gives a much larger value for silver chromate.
    3. Ksp values can be compared directly only for solids with the same ion ratio.

Sources

  • OpenStax Chemistry 15.1. Flowers, P.; Theopold, K.; Langley, R.; Robinson, W. R. Chemistry 2e, section 15.1, Precipitation and Dissolution. OpenStax, 2019. https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/15-1-precipitation-and-dissolution
  • OpenStax Chemistry, Appendix J. Flowers, P.; Theopold, K.; Langley, R.; Robinson, W. R. Chemistry 2e, Appendix J, Solubility Products. OpenStax, 2019. https://openstax.org/books/chemistry-2e/pages/j-solubility-products

How did it go?

Sections read: 0%. Practice: 0 answered.

How was this lesson?