5 percent rule
The small-x shortcut is accepted if x is less than 5 percent of the concentration it was dropped from.
Unit 7: Equilibrium and Solubility, lesson 8
Lesson 7 dropped x from a subtraction to make the algebra easy. That shortcut is not always safe. This lesson gives a test for it, and a way to solve the problem when the test fails. It goes beyond what the AP exam asks you to calculate.
Three quick questions on ideas this lesson uses. They are not scored.
1.What is 0.0030 as a percentage of 0.060?
(0.0030 ÷ 0.060) × 100 = 5.0.
2.A very small K means that, at equilibrium, the mixture is mostly …
Small K means reactants are favored, so little reactant is used up.
3.What is √0.0049?
0.070 × 0.070 = 0.0049.
In lesson 7, a term like 0.50 − x was replaced by 0.50, on the grounds that x was tiny. That turned a hard equation into an easy one.
The shortcut changes the answer a little. If x really is tiny, the change is too small to matter. If x is not tiny, the answer can be badly wrong. So the shortcut always needs a check afterward.[OpenStax Chemistry 13.4]
The usual test is this. After solving with the shortcut, compare x with the starting concentration it was dropped from.
percent change = (x ÷ initial concentration) × 100
If the result is less than 5 percent, the shortcut is accepted. If it is more than 5 percent, the shortcut is rejected, and the equation has to be solved in full.
The number 5 is a convention. It reflects the fact that most K values are only known to two significant figures, so an error of a few percent is no worse than the data.
Step 1. The problem. For A ⇌ B + C, K = 1.0 × 10−6. A flask starts with 0.040 M A.
Step 2. Set up and use the shortcut. K = x2 ÷ (0.040 − x). Drop the x on the bottom: x2 = (1.0 × 10−6)(0.040) = 4.0 × 10−8, so x = 2.0 × 10−4 M.
Step 3. Check. (2.0 × 10−4 ÷ 0.040) × 100 = 0.50 percent. That is far below 5, so the shortcut is fine.
Step 1. The problem. For A ⇌ B + C, K = 0.010. A flask starts with 0.10 M A.
Step 2. Try the shortcut. x2 = (0.010)(0.10) = 0.0010, so x = 0.032 M.
Step 3. Check. (0.032 ÷ 0.10) × 100 = 32 percent. That is far above 5. Nearly a third of the A has reacted, so 0.10 − x is nothing like 0.10. The shortcut is rejected.
You can often tell in advance. The shortcut works when K is small and the starting concentration is large. For a reaction of the form A ⇌ B + C, a handy guide is to divide the starting concentration by K.
In the first case above, 0.040 ÷ (1.0 × 10−6) is 40,000, so it passes easily. In the second, 0.10 ÷ 0.010 is only 10, so it fails.
Try it: is the shortcut safe?
When the shortcut fails, keep the x. For many reactions the equation is then a quadratic, which means the highest power of x is x2. Any quadratic can be arranged like this.
ax2 + bx + c = 0
Its solutions come from the quadratic formula.
x = (−b ± √(b2 − 4ac)) ÷ 2a
Step 1. Start from the full equation. 0.010 = x2 ÷ (0.10 − x)
Step 2. Multiply both sides by the bottom. 0.010(0.10 − x) = x2, which is 0.0010 − 0.010x = x2.
Step 3. Move everything to one side. x2 + 0.010x − 0.0010 = 0. So a = 1, b = 0.010 and c = −0.0010.
Step 4. Use the formula. b2 − 4ac = 0.00010 + 0.0040 = 0.0041, and its square root is 0.0640. So x = (−0.010 ± 0.0640) ÷ 2.
Step 5. Choose the root that makes sense. The two answers are x = 0.027 and x = −0.037. A concentration cannot be negative, so x = 0.027 M.
Step 6. Finish and check. [B] = [C] = 0.027 M and [A] = 0.10 − 0.027 = 0.073 M. Check: (0.027)2 ÷ 0.073 = 0.010. It matches K.
Compare the two answers. The shortcut gave 0.032 M and the full solution gives 0.027 M. The shortcut was off by nearly a fifth.
A quadratic always gives two roots. Only one of them is physically possible. Reject any root that makes a concentration negative, or that uses up more of a reactant than there was to begin with.
The AP exam does not require the quadratic formula. Its problems are chosen so that the equation is a perfect square or the small-x shortcut is clearly fair. You should still know why the shortcut works: when K is very small, very little reactant is used up.
The small-x shortcut is accepted if x is less than 5 percent of the concentration it was dropped from.
Small K and a large starting concentration make the shortcut safe.
x = (−b ± √(b2 − 4ac)) ÷ 2a, for ax2 + bx + c = 0.
Keep the root that gives no negative concentrations.
0 of 7 solved
Check each answer as you go. If you get stuck, open the hint first, then the text solution.
A small-x calculation gives x = 0.0040 M. The initial concentration was 0.20 M. What is x as a percentage of the initial concentration?
(x ÷ initial) × 100.
A small-x calculation gives x = 0.018 M when the initial concentration was 0.12 M. Is the shortcut acceptable?
Work out the percentage.
For reactions of the form A ⇌ B + C, in which case is the small-x shortcut most likely to be safe?
The shortcut needs a small K and a large starting concentration.
For A ⇌ B + C, K = 9.0 × 10−8. A flask starts with 0.10 M A. Use the shortcut to find x, in M.
x2 = K × 0.10.
For A ⇌ B + C, K = 0.050. A flask starts with 0.20 M A. The shortcut fails. Solve x2 + 0.050x − 0.010 = 0 for x, in M.
a = 1, b = 0.050, c = −0.010. Take the positive root.
A quadratic gives x = 0.045 M and x = −0.095 M for a reaction that starts with only reactants. Which root is correct, and why?
The products start at zero and have a concentration of x at equilibrium.
Why is an error of a few percent from the small-x shortcut usually acceptable?
Think about how well K itself is known.
Sections read: 0%. Practice: 0 answered.